The best pie makers in the UK differ primarily in capacity, depth, and power. While a basic model like the Quest Double is a budget-friendly essential for quick snacks, premium options like the Giles & Posner offer extra-deep wells for hearty, pub-style fillings. For larger households, high-wattage machines like the Cooks Professional allow you to bake four pies at once, significantly reducing cooking time compared to a traditional oven.
Whether you are looking for a compact tool for light lunches or a powerful workhorse for family dinners, this guide compares the top-rated machines on the market to help you achieve the perfect golden crust every time.
Note: For Premium Fast Amazon Delivery: Sign up for Amazon Prime . If you are a student ,Sign up here .
1. Cooks Professional Deep Fill Pie Maker (4-Hole)
The Cooks Professional Deep Fill Pie Maker is a 1400W kitchen appliance designed to bake four homemade pies simultaneously in under 10 minutes. Priced under £60, it is a popular “family-sized” option that emphasizes speed and ease of use.
Last update on 2026-03-18 at 02:24 / // Source: Amazon
Key Features & Specs
- Capacity: 4 deep-fill compartments with a built-in crimping edge for a professional, sealed finish.
- Performance: Quick preheat time (under 4 minutes) and high-power 1400W heating for crisp pastry.
- Safety & Convenience: Features a cool-touch handle with a locking latch and non-toxic, PTFE-based non-stick plates for easy food release.
- Included Accessories: Comes with a double-sided pastry cutter (for perfect base and lid sizes) and a spatula.
- Design: Black and silver finish; dimensions are 36 x 26 x 12.5 cm.
User Sentiment Summary
- Pros: Users consistently praise the “lovely results,” noting that it produces deep, crisp pies very quickly. It is generally regarded as very easy to operate.
- Cons: Cleaning receives mixed reviews; because the plates are not removable, some users find wiping them down a bit tedious if filling spills over.
2. Giles & Posner Double Deep Fill Pie Maker (2-Hole)
If you prefer a higher filling-to-pastry ratio, this model is a top choice. It makes two extra-deep pies (9cm diameter but with a significant 7cm depth).
The Giles & Posner Deep Fill Pie Maker (EK4082G) is a specialized 900W electric machine designed to create two extra-deep, pub-style pies. Priced under £50, it is recognized as an “Amazon’s Choice” product for those who prefer a high filling-to-pastry ratio.
Last update on 2026-03-17 at 22:43 / // Source: Amazon
Key Features & Specs
- Capacity: Makes 2 “XL” pies simultaneously.
- Deep-Fill Design: Specifically engineered for generous fillings, with wells measuring 9cm in diameter and a significant 7cm in depth.
- Performance: Reaches a maximum temperature of 200°C with a quick 3.5-minute preheat time. Pies typically cook in about 10 minutes.
- Aesthetics: Features a crimped edge design on the cooking plates to give homemade pies a professional, bakery-style finish.
- Build: Includes non-stick plates, cool-touch handles, a locking latch, and power/ready indicator lights.
- Warranty: Comes with a 3-year warranty (upon registration).
User Sentiment Summary
- Pros: Users are highly satisfied with the size and depth of the pies, describing the results as “crispy and tasty.” Its compact size makes it very easy to store in standard kitchen cupboards.
- Cons: Some European customers noted it comes with a UK 3-pin plug, requiring an adapter for use abroad. A few users mentioned the difficulty of placing raw pastry into the machine while it is already hot, advising caution to avoid finger burns.
Quick Comparison: Cooks Professional vs. Giles & Posner
The Cooks Professional and Giles & Posner pie makers differ primarily in capacity, power, and pie dimensions. The Cooks Professional is a 1400W family-sized machine that makes four pies at once, while the Giles & Posner is a 900W specialist tool that makes two extra-deep “XL” pies with a significant 7cm depth.
3. CucinaPro Mini Pie & Quiche Maker
The CucinaPro Mini Pie & Quiche Maker is a 1000W specialty baker designed to create six bite-sized pies or quiches simultaneously. Priced at £65.88, it is positioned as a high-end gift or holiday tool for party appetizers and snack-sized treats.
Last update on 2026-03-18 at 00:14 / // Source: Amazon
Key Features & Specs
- Capacity: Makes 6 mini pies at once, ideal for portion control or party snacks.
- Included Accessory: Comes with a dough cutting circle to help users measure the exact amount of pastry needed for each slot.
- Build: Features a non-stick interior for easy release and a compact white metal/plastic design (approx. 25cm wide).
- Performance: Designed for quick cooking; however, the manufacturer notes the unit must be fully preheated before adding dough.
- Versatility: Suitable for both savory (quiches, meat pies) and sweet (fruit tarts, jam pies) fillings.
User Sentiment Summary
- Pros: Enthusiastic hobby bakers love the “cute” results and find it fun for batch-making snacks once you master the “learning curve.” Many users report it cooks evenly.
- Cons: The most significant warning for UK/EU buyers is that it often arrives with a US (110v) plug, which is incompatible with UK voltages without a heavy-duty transformer.
- Mixed Feedback: The size is much smaller than some expect—intended for “bite-sized” snacks rather than meal-sized pies. Some users also noted the unit lacks sturdiness and can be tricky to clean if the filling overflows.
Quick Comparison: Family-Sized vs. Snack-Sized
The Cooks Professional and CucinaPro models cater to entirely different needs. The Cooks Professional is a 1400W machine for four meal-sized, deep-fill pies, while the CucinaPro is a 1000W boutique tool designed for six bite-sized party appetizers.
| Feature | Cooks Professional | CucinaPro Mini |
| Pie Capacity | 4 Full-Sized Pies | 6 Bite-Sized Pies |
| Power | 1400 Watts | 1000 Watts |
| Best For | Family Dinners / Lunch | Party Appetizers / Snacks |
| UK Plug? | Yes (UK Brand) | Check listing (often US plug) |
| Typical Price | £54.99 | £65.88 |
4. Quest Double Deep Fill Pie Maker
The Quest Double Deep Fill Pie Maker is a budget-friendly 700W appliance designed for simple, everyday home baking. Currently priced under £30, it is a highly-rated “Amazon’s Choice” product, particularly noted for its compact size and ease of use.
Last update on 2026-03-18 at 02:24 / // Source: Amazon
Key Features & Specs
- Capacity: Makes 2 pies simultaneously, each measuring 9cm in diameter.
- Design: Features a built-in crimping edge to seal pastry and provide a professional finish.
- Included Accessories: Comes with a double-sided pastry cutter to ensure bases and lids are sized perfectly for the 9cm slots.
- Performance: Utilizes a 700W heating element with thermostatic control. Users report a quick 10-minute cooking time.
- Safety & Build: Features non-stick, scratch-resistant plates, cool-touch housing, and non-slip feet.
- UK Focus: Manufactured by a Liverpool-based company, it is fully certified to British safety standards and includes a standard UK plug.
User Sentiment Summary
- Pros: Customers love the value for money and the quality of the “crispy” results. It is frequently praised for working well with various pastry types, including gluten-free options.
- Cons: While marketed as “deep fill,” some users—particularly international reviewers—found the depth (approx. 2cm) to be shallower than expected compared to premium “XL” models.
- Mixed Feedback: The size is polarized; many find it perfect for a single-serving lunch or snack, while others find the resulting pies too small for a main evening meal.
The “Double” Showdown: Quest vs. Giles & Posner
If you are looking for a two-hole pie maker, the choice depends on whether you value price or filling capacity. The Quest is the budget-friendly essential, while the Giles & Posner is the “XL” specialist.
| Feature | Quest Double | Giles & Posner Double |
| Pie Depth | ~2cm (Standard) | 7cm (Extra Deep) |
| Power | 700 Watts | 900 Watts |
| Cutter Included? | Yes | No (Recipe book instead) |
| Best For | Quick snacks & budget prep | Hearty, “Pub-style” deep pies |
5. Salter XL Double Pie Maker
The Salter XL Double Pie Maker is a 900W appliance designed for those who want hearty, pub-style pies with significant volume. It competes directly with the Giles & Posner model, focusing on an extra-deep design that accommodates more filling than standard budget makers.
Last update on 2026-03-17 at 21:03 / // Source: Amazon
Key Features & Specs
- Capacity: Makes 2 “XL” pies at once, featuring a 9cm diameter and an impressive 7cm depth.
- Performance: Reaches a maximum temperature of 190–200°C for golden pastry; pies are typically ready in approximately 10–15 minutes.
- Design: Built-in crimp-edged plates provide a traditional, professional seal to the pastry.
- Safety & Build: Features a quick 3.5-minute preheat, non-stick and scratch-resistant plates, a safety locking latch, and cool-touch housing.
- Extras: Includes a recipe booklet (accessible via QR code) to help users get started with sweet or savory fillings.
User Sentiment Summary
- Pros: Customers highly value the “lovely crispy” results and the significant depth of the pies. Many reviewers highlight it as an energy-efficient alternative to using a conventional oven.
- Cons: While the plates are non-stick, some users report difficulty removing the pies once cooked; others find that because the plates aren’t removable, cleaning can be a bit tricky if fillings overflow.
- International Warning: Similar to other UK brands, international buyers (specifically in Australia) have noted it arrives with a plug incompatible with their local outlets, so it is best suited for the UK market.
Direct Comparison: Salter XL vs. Quest Double
While both are “double” pie makers, the Salter XL is a more powerful, specialized machine for deep-fill enthusiasts.
| Feature | Salter XL Double | Quest Double |
| Pie Depth | 7cm (Extra Deep) | ~2cm (Standard) |
| Power | 900 Watts | 700 Watts |
| Cutter Included? | No (Recipe book only) | Yes |
| Best For | Hearty, “proper” deep pies | Quick snacks / Mince pies |
Pie Maker Buying Guide: What to Look For
1. Capacity: 2-Hole vs. 4-Hole
- 2-Hole (Double): Best for couples, students, or those with limited cupboard space. These are often more compact and easier to store.
- 4-Hole (Family): Ideal for batch cooking or family meals. These machines usually have higher wattage (1400W+) to ensure all four pies cook evenly and stay crisp.
2. The “Deep Fill” Factor
This is the most significant difference between brands.
- Standard (approx. 2cm depth): Best for mince pies, fruit tarts, or light snacks (e.g., Quest Double).
- XL Deep Fill (approx. 7cm depth): Best for “proper” meals with lots of gravy and chunky fillings (e.g., Salter XL or Giles & Posner).
3. Accessories: Cutter Included?
Check if the machine includes a pastry cutter. To get a perfect seal, you need a circular piece of pastry for the base and a slightly smaller one for the lid. If the machine doesn’t include one, you’ll have to measure and cut manually, which can be messy.
4. Plates: Fixed vs. Removable
Most pie makers have fixed plates to ensure even heat distribution. While this makes them sturdier, it makes them harder to clean if a pie “leaks” gravy. Look for high-quality non-stick coatings (like PTFE-free) to ensure the pies slide out easily.
How the Top Models Compare
The Cooks Professional, Salter XL, and Quest Double differ primarily in capacity, depth, and price. The Cooks Professional is a high-power 1400W family machine for four pies, the Salter XL is a 900W specialist for two extra-deep (7cm) pies, while the Quest is a 700W budget-friendly choice for two standard snack-sized pies.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: Do I have to use two types of pastry? A: You don’t have to, but for the best results, pro bakers recommend shortcrust for the base (it’s sturdy and holds the filling) and puff pastry for the lid (it gets light and golden).
Q: Can I put raw meat in a pie maker? A: No. Pie makers cook very quickly (8–12 minutes), which is enough time to crisp pastry but not enough to safely cook raw meat. Always ensure your fillings (stews, curries, or mince) are pre-cooked and cooled before adding them to the pastry.
Q: How do I stop the filling from leaking out? A: Two tips:
- Don’t overfill—leave a 1cm gap at the top.
- Ensure your filling is cold when you put it in. If the filling is hot, it will melt the fat in the raw pastry immediately, causing it to tear.
Q: Are the plates dishwasher safe? A: Generally, no. Most pie makers have fixed plates containing electrical elements. You should wait for the unit to cool and then wipe the non-stick surface with a damp, soapy cloth.
Q: Can I use it for anything other than pies? A: Absolutely. Pie makers are great for:
- Quiches: Pour whisked egg and veg directly into a pastry crust.
- Puff Pastry Pizzas: Use puff pastry and fill with cheese and tomato.
- Omelettes: Many people use them as crustless omelette makers.
Which one is right for you?
- For the “Pub Pie” Experience: Go for the Salter XL Double. Its 7cm depth is unbeatable for chunky fillings.
- For Family Dinners: The Cooks Professional 4-Hole is the most efficient way to feed a group.
- For the Budget-Conscious: The Quest Double is a reliable, no-frills entry point.
Best selling pie makers UK 2026:
Last update on 2026-03-18 at 02:24 / // Source: Amazon
Similar Posts:
Tina Peters has ten years of testing and reviewing kitchen gadgets. I am a home-trained chef. I like to make cakes, pastries, biscuits, icing, and all kinds of home baking/cooking. As someone who likes trying out new kitchen gadgets to up my cooking skills. Over the past ten years, I often find myself buying gadgets like stand mixers, food processors, mini choppers, air fryers, blenders, and all kinds of kitchen appliances. Getting value for your money whenever you purchase an item requires adequate research and testing. So I decided to collate most of the information I have gathered over ten years of using and researching different kitchen gadgets into coxonskitchen.co.uk.